Letters to Amelia

Evelyn C. White

By Lindsay Zier- Vogel

Book *hug Press

281 pages


In the respective epistolary novels The Color Purple and The Quintland Sisters, authors Alice Walker and Vancouver native Shelley Wood enlivened a genre that many literary scholars had dismissed as anachronistic. Both works probed the exploitation of girls within their families and in greater society. 

Now comes Toronto author Lindsay Zier-Vogel with a debut novel with similar themes and tells the story of Grace Porter, a jilted library technician inspired by correspondence between aviator Amelia Earhart and her supposed paramour, Gene Vidal, a former pilot. Earhart and Vidal reportedly first became acquainted in the late 1920s. Both were married at the time “but there were rumours they were lovers from when they met until her disappearance,” the author writes, noting that Grace has been tasked with summarizing their correspondence for her job. “Based on these letters it looks like the rumours were true.” 

Zier-Vogel’s writing transcends the boundaries of time while remaining firmly rooted in the Canadian cultural landscape. After being dumped by her boyfriend, a heartbroken Grace travels solo to Newfoundland where the couple had planned to celebrate their seventh anniversary. There, while marvelling at the colourful “jellybean” houses in St. John’s, she reflects on the province’s tomato soup, lamb stew, and the handcrafted rag rugs that Earhart had allegedly mentioned in a letter to Vidal, effectively blurring the lines between past and present. 

Parallel with Amelia and Gene’s supposed romance, Grace also begins to “deconstruct” her own ill-fated relationship. In a series of steps likely to resonate with anyone who has gone through their own heartbreak, “[she] sits at the end of the bed so she can see a glimpse of the ocean . . . She feels pathetic, then feels rage or grief . . . She opens her email, half-hoping to see something from Jamie, but there’s nothing.” 

Throughout the story, Zier-Vogel keeps her protagonist facing forward while leaning on the past for strength. When Grace herself becomes pregnant, her immersion in the legendary pilot’s triumphs and tragedy continues to influence her as she ponders the pros and cons of motherhood. As she writes the pilot in an imaginary letter, “You didn’t want a baby because you had plans and dreams . . . a baby would’ve kept you from your life, I get that. But would a baby keep me from my life?” At a time when multitudes of women of child-bearing age grapple with the career vs. family conundrum, Zier-Vogel’s smart and fast-paced narrative is especially timely, as the themes of women struggling to ‘do it all’ remain ever-relevant. 

As did Walker and Wood, Zier-Vogel has delivered an impressive epistolary novel that shows how women can take flight and overcome their exploitation despite the socio-cultural obstacles that have historically kept them grounded. 

Halifax writer Evelyn C. White is the author of Alice Walker: A Life (WW Norton, 2004). 

Pre-order Our Next Issue

Room 45.2 Cover

Edited by Lue Palmer
Assistant Edited by Micah Killjoy
Shadow Edited by Ruchika Gothoskar and Omi Rodney

In This Issue: Eberechukwu Peace Akadinma, N.B., Manahil Bandukwala, Chief Lady Bird, Myriam J.A. Chancy, .chisaraokwu., Michelle Contant, Morgan Cross, Jaki Eisman, Ava Fathi, Maria Ford, Jennifer A. Goddard, Michelle Good, Ruchika Gothoskar, Jonsaba Jabbi, Sneha Subramanian Kanta, Micah Killjoy, Moe Kirkpatrick, Lydia Kwa, Margo LaPierre, karen lee, Lynn Hutchinson Lee, Y.S. Lee, Annick MacAskill, Kama La Mackerel, Sarah McPherson, Michie Mee, Zoë Mills, Lue Palmer, Emily Riddle, Alana Rigby, Omi Rodney, Edythe Rodriguez, Victoria Spence Naik, Unimke Ugbong, Nadia Van, semillites hernandez velasco, Dr. Njoki Wane, Yilin Wang, Jenny Heijun Wills, Lacey Yong, Dr. Rachel Zellars, Zhang Qiaohui

Currently on Newsstands

ROOM 45.1, Ancestors
Edited by Serena Lukas Bhandar

In This Issue: Yasmine Ameli, Manahil Bandukwala, Elena Bentley, Meagan Berlin, Serena Lukas Bhandar, Emily Chan, Kathy Crabbe, Asheda Dwyer, francesca ekwuyasi, Mercedes Eng, Lucy Zi Wei Fang, Juliette Blake Jacob, Jessica Jane Khuu, Melissa Kuipers, Holly Lam, Arshiya Malik, Samantha Martin-Bird, Victoria Mbabazi, Nicole Nanayaa M’Carthy, Erin McGregor, Kristin Michelle, Zamina Mithani, Haley Montgomery, Mridula Morgan, Tiffany Morris, Madalyn Murray, Sofia Navarro, Faith Paré, Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha, Maryam Rafiee, Deepa Rajagopalan, Remy Ramirez, Romila, Trish Salah, Jane Shi, jessica ainsli todd, Sara Truuvert, Maneesa Veeravel, Anne Walk, Syrus Marcus Ware, Adrienne Weiss, Evelyn C. White

Join us on Patreon

Become a RoomMate!

Announcing Room’s New Membership Program
Seeking: RoomMates who love literature, events, merchandise, and supporting marginalized creators!


Subscribe to our newsletter

Be the first to know about contests, calls for submissions, upcoming events.

* indicates required

Visit our Store

Share This